NextFin News - Berkshire Hathaway shares closed at $469.32 on Friday, marking a nearly 13% decline from their all-time highs reached in May 2025. This retreat stands in sharp contrast to the broader market, as the S&P 500 index climbed to a fresh record of 7,165.08 during the same period. The widening performance gap—a 26% gain for the S&P 500 versus Berkshire’s double-digit loss over the past year—has triggered a significant reshuffling of the U.S. market capitalization leaderboard, with Walmart officially overtaking Berkshire Hathaway this week to become the ninth most valuable company in the United States.
The divergence comes at a pivotal moment for the Omaha-based conglomerate. U.S. President Trump’s administration has overseen a period of intense market volatility and sector rotation, yet Berkshire has struggled to keep pace with the technology-heavy momentum of the S&P 500. Christopher Davis, a partner at Hudson Value Partners, argues that the market is currently overlooking Berkshire’s intrinsic durability. Davis, whose firm focuses on value-oriented industrial and insurance plays, characterizes Berkshire as a "coiled spring." He suggests that investors are currently overpaying for "HALO" (Heavy Assets, Low Obsolescence) stocks like Caterpillar while ignoring the ultimate HALO play in Berkshire’s insurance and industrial portfolio.
While Davis maintains a bullish long-term stance on Berkshire’s structural advantages, his view is not yet the consensus on Wall Street. The company’s operational performance has drawn scrutiny from analysts who point to stagnating growth. Cathy Seifert, an analyst at CFRA, noted that Berkshire’s operating revenues remained flat last year. Seifert has publicly called for Greg Abel, who took over as CEO following Warren Buffett’s departure at the end of 2025, to outline a more aggressive plan for profit improvement. This skepticism is reflected in the stock’s inability to participate in the recent market rally, as investors demand more clarity on the post-Buffett era.
Internal shifts are already underway under Abel’s leadership. According to reports from The Wall Street Journal, Abel has moved quickly to liquidate positions previously managed by Todd Combs, who recently left the firm to join JPMorgan Chase. The "unloading" of these stakes, estimated to be worth approximately $16 billion, includes significant reductions in holdings such as Amazon, Visa, and Mastercard. This consolidation of power leaves Abel directly responsible for roughly 94% of Berkshire’s $320 billion equity portfolio, signaling a departure from the multi-manager approach Buffett had cultivated for over a decade.
Despite the share price weakness, some institutional observers see a floor emerging. Brian Meredith, an analyst at UBS, recently informed clients that Berkshire is trading at an estimated 8% discount to its intrinsic value. Meredith expects the company to accelerate its share buyback program, raising his 2026 repurchase expectations to $1.7 billion. This technical support, combined with the massive $400 billion cash pile Abel now controls, provides a buffer against further declines, even as the company faces its most significant leadership transition in half a century.
The upcoming annual shareholders meeting in Omaha will serve as the first major test of Abel’s ability to command the "Woodstock for Capitalists" without Buffett on stage. While credential requests remain steady, the focus has shifted from Buffett’s folksy wisdom to Abel’s operational discipline. The central question remains whether Berkshire’s traditional value-driven model can regain its footing in a market that has increasingly favored high-growth technology over the "heavy assets" that define the Berkshire empire.
Explore more exclusive insights at nextfin.ai.
