NextFin News - The euphoria surrounding Pop Mart International Group’s global expansion hit a wall of institutional skepticism this week as China Merchants Securities International (CMSI) issued a rare "Sell" rating on the toy giant. The downgrade follows a 2025 earnings report that, despite showing triple-digit growth, failed to satisfy the heightened expectations of professional analysts who now see a "visibility gap" in the company’s future earnings path.
On March 25, 2026, Pop Mart reported a staggering 184.7% surge in annual revenue to 37.12 billion yuan ($5.4 billion), with net profit skyrocketing 284.5% to 13.08 billion yuan. However, the market’s reaction was swift and brutal: shares plummeted over 16% in the immediate aftermath. The disconnect between the headline growth and the stock price reflects a growing anxiety over the company’s reliance on its breakout IP, Labubu, and a fourth-quarter slowdown that caught many off guard.
CMSI, an institution known for its rigorous fundamental analysis and often cautious stance on high-multiple consumer discretionary stocks, argued that the 2025 results were "worse than expected" when adjusted for the market's whisper numbers. The firm’s analysts noted that while the "Labubu phenomenon" drove 38% of total revenue—contributing 14.16 billion yuan—this concentration creates a precarious "single-pillar" risk. CMSI has historically maintained a disciplined approach to valuation, frequently warning against the sustainability of "fad-driven" consumer trends in the toy and collectibles sector.
This bearish outlook is not yet a consensus on Wall Street or among Hong Kong’s sell-side community. Many analysts still point to Pop Mart’s successful overseas penetration, where revenue grew 291.9% to reach 16.27 billion yuan, now accounting for nearly 44% of the group’s total. Proponents of the stock argue that the upcoming 2026 FIFA World Cup collaboration, featuring Labubu, provides a clear catalyst for further international growth. However, CMSI maintains that the company’s 2026 growth guidance of "no less than 20%" represents a material deceleration that the current valuation cannot support.
The skepticism centers on the durability of intellectual property in a fickle market. Jeff Zhang, an equity analyst at Morningstar, echoed some of these concerns, noting that a slowdown in the final quarter of 2025 has amplified fears regarding the lifecycle of top-tier IPs. While Pop Mart boasts six other IPs with revenue exceeding 2 billion yuan, none have shown the explosive trajectory required to offset a potential cooling of the Labubu craze. The company’s heavy investment in technology and digitalization—utilizing over 745 million HKD of its IPO proceeds by the end of 2025—is seen by bears as a necessary but expensive defensive play rather than a guaranteed growth engine.
The path forward for Pop Mart depends heavily on its ability to institutionalize its creative process. If the company can prove that Labubu is a permanent fixture like Mickey Mouse rather than a passing trend like the Beanie Baby, the CMSI "Sell" rating may eventually look overly pessimistic. For now, the burden of proof has shifted back to management, as investors weigh the reality of a 20% growth target against the triple-digit dreams of the previous year.
Explore more exclusive insights at nextfin.ai.
