NextFin

Hormuz Oil Flows Fall as Iranian Attacks Keep Shipping Risk Elevated

Summarized by NextFin AI
  • Hormuz oil flows fell approximately 77% from 21.6 million barrels per day in Q4 2025 to 4.9 million in Q2 2026, despite the waterway remaining technically open.
  • The disruption affects more than crude: petroleum-product flows declined sharply, while LNG flows fell from 10.5 to 0.8 billion cubic feet per day, straining energy supply and export capacity.
  • Physical volumes may recover as attacks ease and diplomacy improves, but shipping insurance, freight, financing and route premiums could remain elevated because commercial confidence recovers more slowly.
  • The base case is partial normalization: more vessels and regional exports return, while war-risk costs remain above pre-conflict levels unless safe passage becomes routine across both corridors.

NextFin News - Oil shipments through the Strait of Hormuz have fallen as Iranian attacks and warnings keep commercial operators away from the main Gulf export route, but the market is facing a more complicated reality than a simple blockade: regional flows have been sharply reduced while the waterway remains technically open and some cargoes continue to move.

The strategic waterway carries a large share of global oil and liquefied natural gas trade, so every reduction in traffic can become a supply shock. Yet the price response depends on whether the decline is temporary and reversible or whether repeated attacks have changed the economics of moving energy through the Gulf. The evidence points to two forces at once. The lost volumes are primarily a cyclical disruption caused by conflict and vessel risk. The risk premium attached to shipping is more durable because operators can change routes, contracts and insurance assumptions even before the physical flow fully recovers.

The latest official energy data show the scale of the break. The U.S. Energy Information Administration estimates that total oil flows through Hormuz averaged 20.9 million barrels a day in the first quarter of 2025 and 21.6 million barrels a day in the fourth quarter. The estimate fell to 14.9 million barrels a day in the first quarter of 2026 and 4.9 million barrels a day in the second quarter. From the fourth quarter of 2025 to the second quarter of 2026, the estimated flow fell by about 77%.

The same table shows why the disruption matters beyond crude. Petroleum-product flows fell from 5.7 million barrels a day in the fourth quarter of 2025 to 1.1 million barrels a day in the second quarter of 2026. LNG flows fell from 10.5 billion cubic feet a day to 0.8 billion cubic feet a day. The chokepoint is therefore affecting refinery feedstock, transport availability and gas supply at the same time.

Maritime warnings remain severe. The United Kingdom Maritime Trade Operations and the Joint Maritime Information Center said in November that traffic was expected to remain below the 2025 baseline across both the northern Iranian-controlled route and the southern Omani corridor. The advisory cited repeated vessel attacks, route pressure and elevated regional tension. It also recorded a tanker company’s report that its vessel was struck by an unknown projectile while transiting outbound on Nov. 7.

That combination creates the central market question: is Hormuz suffering a temporary war-related interruption, or has Iran made passage so uncertain that the old flow pattern no longer functions? The answer determines whether oil prices eventually retrace the disruption premium or whether every new attack adds to a lasting cost embedded in global energy trade.

The First-Order Shock Is Falling Volumes, Not a Formal Closure

The immediate mechanism is operational rather than legal. A tanker does not need to be formally denied passage to stop sailing. A warning over radio, a projectile strike, disrupted navigation or the withdrawal of war-risk cover can produce the same commercial result: the voyage becomes too uncertain to price, crews become harder to assign, and cargo owners delay loading.

That distinction explains why oil flows can fall sharply even while some vessels continue to transit. The EIA’s quarterly estimates capture physical volumes, while the UKMTO/JMIC advisories capture the decision-making layer above those volumes. A waterway can be technically open while commercial traffic is functionally impaired. The market does not price geography alone; it prices the probability that a ship, cargo or crew will be exposed to force.

The decline from 21.6 million barrels a day in the fourth quarter of 2025 to 4.9 million barrels a day in the second quarter of 2026 is large enough to force production decisions. The EIA estimated that Gulf producers outside Iran collectively shut in 7.5 million barrels a day of crude output in March and expected shut-ins to rise to 9.1 million barrels a day in April under its conflict scenario. The issue was not that the region lacked oil. It was that storage and export access could not absorb normal production.

This is the first important comparison. In a conventional supply disruption, lost barrels are replaced by inventories, spare capacity or alternative routes. In Hormuz, the shock tests all three buffers at once. Producers can cut output, but that protects wells rather than consumers. Buyers can draw inventories, but that only buys time. Alternative pipelines can move some crude, but they cannot instantly replace the waterway’s combined crude, product and LNG capacity.

The price signal is therefore nonlinear. A modest decline in traffic may be absorbed by inventories and rerouting. A larger decline can cause a much bigger increase in freight, insurance and prompt physical premiums because each remaining ship carries more strategic value. This is why oil prices can fall even while the physical system remains fragile: traders may price a partial recovery in volumes before they price a full normalization in risk.

For importers, the most important distinction is between nominal supply and dependable supply. A cargo that can move only after a special warning, a route change or a negotiated exception is not equivalent to a cargo that can be scheduled routinely. That difference raises the value of storage and flexible contracts, even if the headline crude price retreats.

The first-order effect is fewer barrels through the chokepoint. The deeper effect is a less neutral market in which security conditions influence which cargoes can be delivered, when they can arrive and what financing terms attach to them.

Why a Severe Traffic Shock Has Not Locked Oil Prices at the Peak

The market’s response has been restrained because physical flows, expectations and diplomatic risk are moving in different directions. Increasing flows can lower the prompt supply premium before the security problem is fully solved.

The EIA reported that Brent spot had fallen by more than $30 a barrel from its October monthly average by Nov. 18, with steadily increasing Hormuz flows helping to push prices lower. That observation separates two questions that are often blended together: whether the waterway is safe, and whether marginal barrels are becoming more available. Prices can fall on the second question even while the first remains unresolved.

The EIA’s earlier outlook provides the cyclical template. In April, the agency assumed that the conflict would not persist beyond that month and projected that production shut-ins would fall from 9.1 million barrels a day in April to 6.7 million barrels a day in May, with production moving close to pre-conflict levels later in the year. That was a conditional forecast, not a description of the eventual outcome. It nevertheless shows how the market expects a conflict-driven supply shock to mean-revert: traffic improves, storage pressure eases, and shut-in production returns.

Hormuz is also unusually large relative to other maritime chokepoints. The EIA’s 2025 estimates put total oil flows above 20 million barrels a day in every quarter, compared with roughly 4.6 million to 5.9 million barrels a day through the Suez Canal and SUMED pipeline. The comparison does not mean every Hormuz barrel is irreplaceable, but it shows why a prolonged interruption cannot be solved by sending all cargoes around another route.

The market can still look through the disruption if it believes three conditions will hold. First, enough vessels must continue moving to prevent inventories from tightening at the margin. Second, producers must retain the ability to restart shut-in output once export access improves. Third, diplomatic or military arrangements must reduce the probability of another attack before replacement barrels are needed.

“I am ready to start working immediately in negotiations to establish a humanitarian framework to evacuate all vessels and seafarers trapped. However, for this to materialize, I will need the understanding, commitment and, above all, the concrete actions from all relevant countries and stakeholders,” IMO Secretary-General Arsenio Dominguez said on March 19, 2026.

The statement illustrates the importance of diplomacy as a supply variable. If a safe-passage framework reduces the probability of attack, traffic can recover before the political dispute is fully resolved. Commodity prices are forward-looking; a tanker need not be safe today if traders believe it will be safe before inventories become critically tight.

But reopening a route physically is faster than rebuilding confidence commercially. The November UKMTO/JMIC material still described traffic as reduced and the threat level as severe even as the EIA reported increasing flows. That divergence is crucial. One measures barrels that have moved. The other measures the risk faced by the next voyage.

The cyclical call is therefore specific: the physical volume shock should mean-revert if the attack rate falls and export access improves. The structural call is narrower: the cost of proving that the route is safe can remain elevated after volumes recover. The article’s central judgment rests on that split rather than on a prediction that Hormuz will remain closed.

The Second-Order Effect Is a Repricing of Reliability

The second-order transmission runs from crude flows into shipping finance, refined products, LNG and inflation expectations. The scarce asset is not only oil; it is reliable delivery.

When a vessel faces a higher probability of attack, the cost can spread across several contracts. War-risk insurance can become more expensive. Charterers can demand compensation for waiting time and route changes. Owners can require a premium to use a route exposed to Iranian-controlled waters. Banks and commodity traders can apply tighter collateral terms when a cargo may be delayed, seized or stranded. These costs can rise even when the crude price itself is falling.

That creates a cross-market effect. A lower Brent price can coexist with higher delivered fuel costs for an importer if freight, insurance and demurrage absorb the decline. Refiners with secure access to crude can be insulated relative to refiners dependent on vulnerable Gulf cargoes. LNG buyers face an even sharper problem because the EIA estimates that Hormuz LNG flows fell from 10.5 billion cubic feet a day in the fourth quarter of 2025 to 0.8 billion cubic feet a day in the second quarter of 2026. Gas markets cannot always substitute quickly among cargoes, pipelines and storage.

The market’s second-order mistake would be to treat recovering flow as recovering reliability. Traders may see more vessels and conclude that the shock is over. Industrial buyers may see a route that remains exposed to attack and conclude that future delivery is less dependable. If the second group is right, spot oil can understate the persistence of the risk premium.

This is where the conflict can become structural without permanently closing the strait. Repeated attacks can change procurement rules. Buyers can hold more inventory outside the Gulf. Shipowners can diversify fleets, flags and routes. Producers can invest in alternative pipelines and storage. Insurers can maintain stricter terms. None of these changes requires a formal blockade. They require only enough uncertainty to make the previous low-risk operating model uneconomic.

The historical comparison is useful but limited. The Red Sea disruption showed that individual voyages can remain possible while some operators avoid a route and accept longer journeys. The 2022 sanctions shock showed that trade can reroute through different intermediaries and destinations without every affected barrel disappearing. In both cases, flows adapted, but the old pattern of low-friction trade did not automatically return.

Hormuz is likely to follow that two-speed pattern. Volumes can mean-revert; the cost of proving that they are safe may not.

The Strongest Counter-Thesis: Iran Still Needs the Waterway Open

The strongest case against a lasting disruption is strategic self-interest. Iran relies on oil exports, Asian buyers and maritime access. A policy that blocks Gulf neighbors while allowing some cargoes to move may be coercive, but a policy that stops all shipping would also damage Tehran’s revenue, raise the risk of direct military intervention and alienate countries whose support it needs.

This counter-thesis has real force. The fact that some cargoes continue to move shows that the waterway has not become an absolute barrier. The EIA’s observation that flows were increasing by November also suggests that commercial traffic can resume when operators receive enough security and political assurance. If a negotiated framework protects selected routes or grants passage to selected flags, the physical market could normalize faster than the political headlines imply.

Under this view, the decline in Hormuz shipments is a cyclical bargaining tool. Iran raises the cost of passage to pressure adversaries, but ultimately allows enough traffic to prevent a full energy crisis. Producers restart output as storage constraints ease. Oil prices lose the conflict premium, and the market returns to fundamentals such as demand, inventories and producer policy.

That argument is more persuasive for crude volumes than for shipping economics. A selective-access regime can keep barrels moving while still preventing a return to a neutral, low-friction market. It can also create a hierarchy in which some operators receive practical access while other exporters face higher risk. In that case, the waterway is open in a technical sense but segmented in a commercial sense.

The counter-thesis would win if the security system normalized rather than merely permitting exceptions. The falsifying signal for the structural-risk call is a sustained sequence in which UKMTO/JMIC threat assessments fall materially from severe, reported vessel attacks remain at zero for at least eight consecutive weeks, and traffic returns close to the 2025 baseline across both routes. If those conditions arrive together, the claim that the risk architecture has changed would be wrong.

Conversely, a new attack followed by another material fall in flows would show that lower spot oil prices are masking a continuing physical constraint. Iran may need Hormuz open, but it does not need Hormuz to operate as it did before the attacks.

What the Disruption Means Across Time Horizons

In the short term, sentiment and liquidity dominate. Each attack or warning can widen the spread between nearby and deferred crude contracts, lift tanker rates and push buyers toward prompt cargoes. The upside oil scenario is a confirmed attack on a high-volume tanker or an interruption that cuts flows back toward the second-quarter estimate of 4.9 million barrels a day. The downside is a credible safe-passage arrangement that moves traffic materially higher and releases stranded barrels into a market already watching inventories.

In the medium term, fundamentals depend on whether shut-in production returns. The EIA estimated 7.5 million barrels a day of regional crude shut-ins in March and 9.1 million barrels a day in April under its conflict scenario. If those barrels return while demand remains soft, the physical market can loosen quickly and cap oil prices. If output remains curtailed because storage, insurance and export access stay constrained, the market will face a tighter balance even if headline shipping counts improve.

In the long term, the winners and losers are defined by reliability rather than by a single oil-price direction. Producers with alternative export routes, secure storage and diversified customers are better insulated. Gulf exporters dependent on Hormuz bear the greatest exposure. LNG buyers and refiners without flexible feedstock options face higher delivered costs. Shipowners and insurers may capture higher risk premiums, but only if they can manage the possibility of loss.

The base case is partial normalization: more vessels move, regional exports improve, and oil prices retreat from the most acute disruption premium, while freight and war-risk costs remain above their pre-conflict structure. The upside case for supply is a verified security framework that restores traffic across both corridors and allows shut-in production to return. The downside case is a new series of attacks that pushes flows back toward the second-quarter trough and forces more Gulf producers to reduce output.

The key data points are not only Brent and daily tanker counts. They are the share of traffic using each route, the number of reported attacks, war-risk insurance terms, LNG cargo availability and the pace at which regional production restarts. If those indicators improve together, the disruption was mainly cyclical. If oil volumes recover but route premiums and exclusions remain elevated, the market is entering a new operating regime.

As of Nov. 21, 2026, the evidence supports a two-speed conclusion: the barrels can come back before confidence does. Hormuz will not be economically normal until safe passage becomes routine rather than exceptional.

Explore more exclusive insights at nextfin.ai.

Insights

What makes Hormuz a global chokepoint?

Why can traffic fall without closure?

How sharply did Hormuz flows decline?

Which flows face the biggest losses?

Why can oil prices fall amid risk?

How do attacks raise shipping costs?

What is the role of safe-passage talks?

Could Iran keep Hormuz open selectively?

How does Hormuz compare with Suez?

What did Red Sea rerouting teach?

What could restore Hormuz traffic?

Will war-risk costs outlast oil shocks?

Which data show lasting market change?

How might LNG buyers adapt to disruption?

What signal would disprove lasting risk?

Search, ask or analyze anything...