NextFin News - A new exchange-traded fund is attempting to institutionalize one of the most persistent anomalies in the digital asset market: the tendency for Bitcoin to generate the vast majority of its returns while U.S. markets are closed. The Tidal Bitcoin Overnight Strategy ETF, which filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission on Wednesday, aims to capture price appreciation during the "night" session—defined as the period between the 4:00 p.m. New York close and the 9:30 a.m. open the following day.
The fund’s strategy is built on a decade of data showing that Bitcoin’s performance during regular U.S. trading hours has been remarkably stagnant compared to its behavior in the off-hours. According to data compiled by Bloomberg, a hypothetical investor who held Bitcoin only during U.S. market hours since 2014 would have seen a cumulative return of roughly 15%, while an investor holding only during the overnight session would have seen gains exceeding 2,000%. This "night effect" is not unique to crypto—it has been documented in the S&P 500 for decades—but the magnitude of the discrepancy in the 24/7 crypto market is significantly more pronounced.
Isabelle Lee, a reporter at Bloomberg who has tracked ETF innovations, notes that the filing comes as U.S. President Trump’s administration has signaled a more permissive regulatory environment for specialized crypto products. The proposed ETF would not hold Bitcoin directly during the day; instead, it would use a combination of spot Bitcoin and derivatives to gain exposure at the New York close and exit or hedge that position by the next morning’s bell. This approach seeks to bypass the "midday slump" often attributed to institutional rebalancing and the liquidity drains that occur when traditional financial desks are most active.
The strategy is championed by a subset of quantitative analysts who argue that Bitcoin’s price discovery is increasingly driven by Asian and European market participants, as well as automated retail trading bots that operate without regard for the New York clock. However, this view is far from a consensus. Critics, including several senior analysts at JPMorgan, have previously argued that the "night effect" is a statistical mirage that fails to account for transaction costs and the widening of bid-ask spreads during low-liquidity periods. They suggest that once the costs of entering and exiting positions twice daily are factored in, the alpha from the overnight session may evaporate.
Furthermore, the reliance on historical "night" outperformance assumes that the entry of massive spot ETFs—such as those from BlackRock and Fidelity—has not fundamentally altered the market's plumbing. Since the launch of spot Bitcoin ETFs in early 2024, the concentration of liquidity around the 4:00 p.m. "fix" has increased, potentially shifting the timing of price movements. If more capital begins to chase the overnight anomaly through products like the Tidal ETF, the very trade they are trying to exploit could be "arbed away," as increased buying pressure at the New York close and selling at the open flattens the return profile.
The success of the fund will likely depend on whether the volatility of the daytime session remains a net negative for holders. During periods of macro-economic stress, Bitcoin often trades as a high-beta risk asset, frequently selling off alongside the Nasdaq during U.S. hours. By "sleeping" through these sessions, the ETF hopes to offer a smoother ride, though it risks missing out on the explosive, news-driven rallies that occasionally ignite during the American afternoon. For now, the filing stands as a testament to the market's ongoing obsession with timing a 24-hour asset that never truly rests.
Explore more exclusive insights at nextfin.ai.
