NextFin News - President Donald Trump signed an executive order on Friday evening that implemented the Lindsey O. Graham Sanctioning Russia and Iran Act of 2026 — then immediately waived the law's core sanctions, including 500 percent tariffs on Russian goods and 100 percent duties on the world's largest buyers of Russian oil and gas, just two days before they were set to take effect. The waivers, which Trump certified to Congress as "in the national interests of the United States," clear the way for the administration's opening to Russian energy supplies and mark a sharp reversal of the years-long U.S. campaign to starve the Kremlin of fuel revenue.
What the Order Actually Did
The executive order, dated October 16, 2026, did not repeal the law. It did something more unusual: it put the Graham Act's machinery in place and then switched it off. Under Section 2, the order raised the duty rate on all goods from the Russian Federation by 500 percent ad valorem and set a 100 percent duty on goods from each of the five largest importers of Russian-origin crude oil and natural gas — triggered if any of those countries knowingly made new purchases on or after October 18, 2026. A separate 100 percent duty was set for the top five facilitators of Russian oil sanctions evasion. Section 4 then waived all of it.
Trump invoked Section 115 of the Graham Act, which allows the president to waive "the application of any sanctions provision" against foreign persons, any restriction against persons, and any duty, provided he submits a written certification to Congress that the waiver is in the national interest, plus a report explaining the basis. In the order, he wrote:
"I am hereby waiving the application of such sanctions, restrictions, and duties provided for in the Graham Act. I have submitted to the Congress a certification that the issuance of such a waiver at this time is in the national interests of the United States."
The White House did not release the certification's reasoning. The order says the waivers will remain in place until administration officials "determine that further action is appropriate," and directs the U.S. Trade Representative, in consultation with the State, Treasury, and Energy secretaries, to monitor countries that buy Russian energy or help Russia evade sanctions — and to recommend further action.
The timing matters. The 100 percent tariffs on major Russian-energy importers were scheduled to take effect on Sunday, October 18. The order stopped them roughly 48 hours before the deadline. The law itself was signed on September 18, 2026, and was renamed posthumously for Senator Lindsey Graham, the South Carolina Republican who championed it and died in July 2026. The final version passed the Senate on August 7 by a vote of 86–11 and the House on September 16 by 262–159, after Graham's death prompted colleagues to revive the measure in his name. Beyond the Russia measures, the act extends the Iran Sanctions Act by five years, to 2031.
The Energy Logic Behind the Reversal
The waiver did not come out of nowhere. One week earlier, the administration announced a deal with Moscow under which Russia would supply diesel to U.S. and global markets: an initial tranche of 300,000 tons, a further 500,000 tons in November, and then one million tons "immediately thereafter." The Treasury Department's Office of Foreign Assets Control issued a general license authorizing Russian diesel imports, effective through April 6, 2027.
The stated objective is fuel prices. Brent crude futures fell $1.54, or 1.47 percent, to $103.18 a barrel on October 12 after the diesel deal was announced, while U.S. West Texas Intermediate crude dropped 1.68 percent to $90.31. The average U.S. diesel price stood at $6.28 a gallon, down from a record $6.53 at the end of September. On the day of the waiver itself, oil eased again: Brent fell 71 cents, or 0.67 percent, to $105.21 a barrel by early trading, and WTI dropped 77 cents, or 0.79 percent, to $97.20.
But the market's relief has been partial and conditional. Brent remained above $100 a barrel even after the diesel announcement, reflecting a persistent Middle East risk premium from the U.S.-Iran conflict that no amount of Russian diesel can fully erase. The waiver is a bet that incremental supply will cool pump prices ahead of the midterm elections — not that it will normalize the global oil market.
The administration has also pushed for an "energy ceasefire" between Russia and Ukraine, under which both sides would stop attacking each other's energy infrastructure. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy initially said he would abide by it, then said earlier in the week that Ukraine would no longer hold off on striking Russian refineries. The waiver effectively treats Russian energy as a tool of de-escalation rather than as revenue for a war machine — the exact framing Kyiv rejects.
The Politics: A Law Passed, Then Undone
The reversal has drawn bipartisan fire. On October 13, a group of senators wrote that the diesel deal "is a gift to our adversary and a betrayal of our Allies; it should be rescinded." The letter was signed by Democrats Richard Blumenthal, Jeanne Shaheen, Dick Durbin, Sheldon Whitehouse, Jack Reed, and Chris Coons, and Republicans Mitch McConnell, Susan Collins, Alan Armstrong, Lisa Murkowski, and John Cornyn.
Later in the week, lawmakers pressed the administration to "revoke this license and not issue further general licenses that reopen Russian energy transactions and restore revenue to the Kremlin's war chest." Zelenskyy, in a Wednesday interview, said he felt "betrayed" by the decision:
"It's more complicated than just my emotions or just my feelings. Yes, it depends not on me. Our country has to survive."
The episode also underscores a structural tension in the legislation itself. Congress wrote Section 115's waiver authority into the Graham Act precisely because a blanket sanctions regime leaves the president no room to maneuver — and then used that escape hatch within a month. The law's leverage now depends less on the tariffs Congress wrote than on the monitoring and reporting the order assigns to the Trade Representative.
This is not the first time a sanctions law has contained a presidential waiver; such provisions are common precisely because Congress knows it cannot foresee every diplomatic contingency. What is unusual is the speed and scope of its use — a comprehensive package, signed with ceremony, neutralized before a single duty took effect. The practical effect is that the Graham Act now functions as a monitoring regime with dormant teeth, rather than as an automatic constraint.
Second-Order Effects: Who Gains, Who Is Exposed
The first-order effect is straightforward: Russian oil and diesel flow more freely, and the threat of 100 percent tariffs on China, India, Turkey, and other major buyers is suspended. The second-order effects are where the real trade-offs sit.
For global oil markets, the waiver adds a marginal supply cushion but does not remove the dominant risk premium. The Strait of Hormuz remains a chokepoint under stress from the Iran conflict; Russian volumes are a supplement, not a substitute, for disrupted Middle East flows. That means the waiver is more likely to cap the upside in diesel cracks than to drive a sustained decline in crude. Goldman Sachs estimated that 800,000 metric tons of Russian supply would cut Gulf Coast and European wholesale diesel by $1 to $2 a barrel — a meaningful but bounded effect.
For U.S. refiners and consumers, the calculus is more favorable. Diesel is the tightest refined product in the system, and Russian diesel was a major source of global supply before 2022. Allowing it back in — even in limited tonnages — eases the refining margin squeeze that has kept pump prices elevated. The political payoff is direct: diesel prices are the most visible fuel cost for trucking, agriculture, and heating, and midterms amplify the salience of every cent at the pump.
For Ukraine, the exposure is asymmetric. The waiver restores a revenue stream to Russia at a moment when Kyiv is negotiating from a position of military strain, and it does so without any visible concession from Moscow on the battlefield. The counter-argument — that cheaper fuel helps Ukraine's own economy and that isolating Russia completely has failed to end the war — is real, but it is a long-term structural argument, not a near-term political one.
There is also a credibility dimension for U.S. sanctions policy. Allies that have borne real costs to wean themselves off Russian energy now face a U.S. that has paused enforcement of a law barely a month old. The risk is not that the waiver itself is illegal — Section 115 plainly authorizes it — but that future sanctions legislation will be discounted by partners who expect the escape hatch to be used. Sanctions work largely through expectations of durability; a waiver that arrives before the first deadline teaches markets and allies to price in reversibility.
The Counter-Case, and What Would Break It
The strongest argument against the waiver is that it trades sanctions leverage for a supply signal that may be too small to matter. Critics note that global fuel prices are elevated primarily because of the Iran conflict, not because of a Russian diesel shortage, and that the Kremlin gains propaganda and revenue value from the deal regardless of the actual tonnage delivered. If Russian shipments stall, or if Middle East disruptions deepen, the administration gets neither lower prices nor diplomatic credit — and has handed away a sanctions tool in the process.
The counter-argument rests on a different reading of leverage: that maximum pressure has not ended the war, that energy markets are fungible enough that Russian barrels find buyers anyway, and that a targeted supply release is a more useful instrument than a tariff that would also punish U.S. allies. That view treats the waiver as tactical, not permanent — a pause to test whether supply can do what sanctions could not.
The falsifying signal is specific. If Brent crude fails to break below $100 a barrel within two weeks of the diesel deliveries beginning, and if the average U.S. diesel price does not decline by at least 10 cents a gallon from the $6.28 level by the end of November, the supply-relief thesis is wrong — and the waiver will have cost sanctions leverage without delivering its stated economic benefit.
What to Watch
Three signals will determine whether this waiver is a tactical pivot or a durable policy shift. First, the actual volume of Russian diesel that reaches U.S. and global markets against the announced tranches of 300,000, 500,000, and one million tons. Second, whether the monitoring and reporting the order assigns to the Trade Representative produces any new designations — or whether the waiver simply becomes permanent by inertia. Third, the congressional response: with the law's waiver certification now on record, lawmakers can still move to disapprove, but they would need the votes to override.
Short term, expect oil to trade the waiver as a modest bearish supply signal capped by Middle East risk. Medium term, the question is whether Russian volumes prove reliable enough to rewire European and Asian buyers' sourcing. Long term, the structural question is whether the U.S. has redefined sanctions as a negotiable instrument rather than a fixed constraint — and whether allies will price that uncertainty into their own energy and defense planning.
Scenarios: in the base case, Russian diesel flows in the announced tranches, diesel cracks narrow by $1 to $2 a barrel, and pump prices drift lower into the election period without a sustained break in crude. In the upside case for the administration, the energy ceasefire holds, Middle East risk premia fade, and Brent falls toward the low $90s — a genuine relief rally. In the downside case, shipments stall or the Iran conflict widens, Brent retests the mid-$100s, and the waiver is remembered as leverage surrendered for nothing.
The waiver is not a repeal. It is a pause with a political clock attached — and the test is whether the administration can show, before that clock runs out, that cheaper fuel was worth the leverage it gave away.
Explore more exclusive insights at nextfin.ai.
