NextFin

Fed Funds Futures Debate Rate Cut Prospects After Powell’s Cautious November 2025 Guidance

NextFin news, On October 29, 2025, the Federal Reserve convened its Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) meeting in Washington D.C., leading to a 10–2 vote to cut the federal funds rate by 25 basis points, bringing the target range to 3.75%–4.00%. This marked the Fed's second rate cut in 2025, aimed at cushioning a gradually cooling labor market, as noted in their official statement. Concurrently, the Fed announced a suspension of quantitative tightening (QT) by halting the runoff of its $6.6 trillion bond portfolio starting December 1, signaling renewed liquidity support to money markets amid recent strains.

The rate decision was followed by Chair Jerome Powell’s press conference, where he took an unusually candid tone regarding the next FOMC meeting scheduled for December 9–10, 2025. Powell emphasized a policy stance “not on a preset course,” underscoring that a further rate cut in December is “not a foregone conclusion,” revealing sharply differing views among Fed officials on how to proceed. Powell highlighted that inflation remains “somewhat elevated,” with core Personal Consumption Expenditures (PCE) inflation rising from about 2.3% in spring to 2.7% by August, possibly peaking near 3% year-end due to new tariffs. He also flagged labor market softness influenced more by supply constraints—such as a shrinking workforce—than by demand weakness.

Adding to the complexity, a federal government shutdown has halted routine economic releases—including September and October employment and inflation reports—forcing the Fed to rely on private data sources. Powell metaphorically described the situation as “driving in the fog,” necessitating a cautious, data-dependent approach to policy.

The immediate market response was volatile. Following the announcement, equity markets initially rallied, with the S&P 500 up by 0.5%, but gains were erased as Powell’s hawkish tone took hold, leaving the S&P 500 flat for the session. Treasury yields jumped, with the 10-year yield rising to approximately 4.06%, reflecting tempered expectations for near-term easing. The U.S. dollar strengthened modestly against other major currencies. Despite this short-term whipsaw, U.S. equities extended their broader October rally, with all major indices closing October at multi-month or year-high levels, buoyed by strong corporate earnings such as Amazon’s positive outlook.

The Fed’s internal division was stark: two dissenters at the October meeting had polar opposite views—one favoring no cut due to inflation concerns and another advocating a 50 basis point cut to support the labor market. The division highlights the challenge the Fed faces balancing lingering inflation near 2.7% against early signs of employment weakening. Notably, Fed Governor Christopher Waller, generally hawkish, publicly called for more easing post-meeting, emphasizing support for the labor market amid its softening despite inflation risks.

Market pricing via Fed funds futures, tracked by the CME FedWatch tool, adjusted swiftly after Powell’s remarks; probabilities for a December 25 basis points cut declined to around 65–70% from near 90% beforehand. Long-term projections imply a gradual easing cycle through 2026, with the federal funds rate expected to drift toward 3.0% by late next year, contingent on inflation’s trajectory and labor market developments.

This cautious outlook stems from Powell’s observation that the rate cuts' effectiveness could be limited as labor market slack arises mainly from supply-side factors—immigration restrictions, retirements, and changing workforce participation—not demand drops that can be stimulated by cheaper credit. This phenomenon creates a “pushing on a string” predicament in monetary policy, complicating the Fed’s mandate to promote maximum employment alongside price stability.

Analyzing these developments reveals several key dynamics: firstly, inflation remains elevated but shows signs of easing, with supply chain pressures having abated and earlier tight policy slowing demand-sensitive sectors. Secondly, the labor market is cooling but not unraveling; unemployment edged up modestly to 4.3%, still historically low, reflecting a “bifurcated” economy with disparate consumer segments. Thirdly, the data blackout due to the government shutdown injects significant uncertainty, forcing a reliance on private payroll estimates and regional Fed surveys, which amplifies market volatility and complicates forward guidance.

Investors are thus navigating a nuanced environment where the Fed appears to be preparing for a “soft landing”—aiming to lower inflation to 2% without triggering a recession. The recent rate cuts and pause in QT collectively loosen financial conditions, providing modest stimulus while keeping policy tools ready if risks materialize. Market reactions suggest tentative acceptance of this approach, with stock rallies and contained bond yields reinforcing expectations that the Fed is near the end of its hiking cycle but not done cutting.

Looking ahead, the December FOMC decision will hinge critically on forthcoming private sector employment data and any early signals that inflation is either accelerating or receding faster than anticipated. Should the labor market deterioration prove sharper-than-expected, or inflation continue rolling over, the Fed may resume easing. Conversely, resilient job growth or sticky inflation would justify further policy restraint, possibly ending 2025’s easing cycle with a pause.

These developments reveal an evolving trend in Fed policymaking under President Donald Trump’s administration during 2025—marked by a transition from aggressive tightening toward calibrated easing with an elevated emphasis on data dependency amid significant uncertainty. Economists remain divided: some, like Michael Pearce of Oxford Economics, anticipate a data-dependent pause while others, including market strategists like Michael Arone, foresee one more cut in December amid labor market weakness.

In sum, the current discourse reflected in Fed funds futures underlines a Fed caught between achieving an inflation soft landing and navigating a complex labor market landscape compounded by a lack of precise data. The nuanced guidance from Chair Powell has injected prudence into market expectations, tempering earlier assumptions of inevitable rate cuts, and setting the stage for a potentially volatile but measured period in U.S. monetary policy as 2025 draws to a close and 2026 approaches.

Investors and policymakers alike will be closely monitoring private employment surveys, inflation proxies, and indicators of consumer and business confidence in the coming weeks. The Fed’s ability to successfully calibrate its policy stance in this environment will be critical to sustaining economic growth, taming inflation, and maintaining financial stability amid the unprecedented challenges posed by data blackouts and divergent economic signals.

According to Investing.com, the ongoing debate within the Fed and in financial markets highlights the delicate balancing act of monetary policy in a mid-cycle phase, where rate cuts are no longer a given but remain possible, contingent on evolving economic data and risks to the outlook. This represents a departure from earlier 2025 expectations of steady easing, emphasizing instead a more nuanced, meeting-by-meeting assessment framework that signals data sensitivity, internal divergence, and adaptive policy discretion.

Explore more exclusive insights at nextfin.ai.

Open NextFin App