NextFin news, New Delhi, this Tuesday — The Supreme Court of India sharply criticized the Centre for its failure to provide proper infrastructure and facilities to retired judges appointed to tribunals, which has resulted in many of them refusing such appointments. The bench, comprising Justices B V Nagarathna and R Mahadevan, expressed concern over the lack of dignity and amenities extended to former chief justices and high court judges who accept tribunal posts.
The Court observed that retired judges often decline tribunal appointments after realizing the poor conditions, including inadequate office infrastructure, lack of stationery, absence of housing arrangements, and insufficient official vehicles. The bench remarked that the fault lies with the Centre, which created these tribunals but failed to ensure basic facilities for their members.
Addressing the Additional Solicitor General Vikramjit Banerjee, the bench highlighted that tribunal chairpersons, some of whom are former chief justices or Supreme Court judges, are provided with the "rickety" vehicles and have to repeatedly request for essential resources. The Court urged the government to treat former judges with dignity and respect.
The Supreme Court further stated that if the Centre is unable to provide proper facilities, it should consider abolishing all tribunals and transfer their matters to the high courts. The bench called for the formation of a committee comprising various ministries, including the Department of Personnel and Training (DoPT), to identify and address the lapses in tribunal administration.
The issue arose during the hearing of a plea filed by the National Green Tribunal (NGT) Bar Association Western Zone concerning vacancies in tribunals. The Centre informed the Court that two ex-judges offered appointments did not take charge, necessitating a fresh appointment process, which would take time. The Court did not agree to the petitioner’s request to allow existing members to continue beyond retirement until new appointments are made.
The Supreme Court has scheduled the next hearing on this matter for December 16, 2025.
Source: LiveLaw, Business Standard, ETV Bharat (September 16, 2025)
Explore more exclusive insights at nextfin.ai.